Inside Baseball: Top 50 FAs, ranked by dollars
He throws hard, logs big innings, never had any arm trouble, just turned 30 and is generally considered one of the game’s best pitchers. He’s also a very good team player, as was shown in this year’s postseason. The only knock is the uneven career October performances. There’s no reason to think he won’t match Max Scherzer‘s haul from a year ago. The Dodgers and Cubs, who have the wherewithal, the interest and the connections are the early favorites. It wouldn’t shock anyone if new Red Sox president Dave Dombrowski, who traded for him in Detroit, takes a peek. Toronto isn’t going to pony up this kind of money, no matter what anyone says now. $210M, 7 years. The slugger who’s hit 45-plus home runs two of the last three years goes into free agency with a bang. It doesn’t hurt that he can play first base well, right field adequately and third base and left field passably. He’s been connected to the Mariners, Red Sox, Blue Jays and Cardinals. But the Orioles, which just won a big-buck lawsuit, probably need to do what they can to keep him. One caveat: If he stays, he probably still gets less. $182M, 7 years. Some might suggest he hasn’t lived up to his billing, and yet, he’s about to sign a contract that approaches $200 million. He’s one of the best defensive outfielders in the game, runs the bases well and shows occasional pop. The big bonus is that he’s still only 26. The knocks: not a proven 3 or 4 hitter, and great vs. left-handers. $180M, 9 years. Folks can knock the history of big free-agent deals for starting pitchers all they want, but Greinke’s first $147 million deal was boffo for the Dodgers. He opted out with $71 million to go, but should easily double that. LA likely has him as its top target after his 1.66 ERA and possible Cy Young Award, with Price as the second call. The Giants and Cubs are other obvious possibilities. $165M, 5 years. He’s a big power hitter and he’s only 28. While he’s frequently been on the trade block, there’s really no good reason for it. He should get more than Jacoby Ellsbury‘s $153 million. $161M, 7 years. Some may nitpick his postseason, but his incredible power-speed combo should play. he sparked the Mets like no other summer pickup, and he showed he’s willing to play center field (though he’s much better in left). $150M, 6 years. He answered the doubters with two enormous postseason performances, the most vital one in Game 5 of the ALDS (and the complete game in Game 2 of the World Series wasn’t bad, either). He was throwing up to 95 mph, so there’s no reason to give credence to the whispers about his elbow. It is fair to say he wasn’t as good with the Royals as he’s been all these years with the Reds. But he finished with a flourish, despite a couple uncharacteristic performances late. $144M, 6 years. He did what he needed to do to get the nine-figure deal. The Nats were a mess this year, but he remained solid. The Cubs make sense for the Wisconsin product. $115M, 5 years. The Royals probably won’t give him more than three or four years, as they hope to capitalize on a possible hometown discount (Gordon is from Lincoln, Neb.) but he probably can get five elsewhere. The best left fielder in the game. The Orioles, Astros, Cubs and White Sox were heard as four of many possibilities. $100M, 5 years. After a very rough start, he showed some semblance of his considerable talent in the second half. $90M, 6 years. Scouts still love him — the athleticism, the competitiveness, the arm (and the lack of innings on that arm). Yet, his platform year was mostly a disaster. He has some connections to the Yankees and Tigers, who both need starters. The guess is, he still recovers what he turned down with the Cubs. $85M, 5 years. One of the most underrated pitchers in the game, who did well pitching in a hitters’ park and in a hitters’ division, and he should do well here. The second best lefty on market. $80M, 5 years. He went home, and did a terrific job. Texas would like him back, but that bat is wasted in the AL. $75M, 5 years. He is consistent, durable and productive. He also can hit. The Giants, Diamondbacks and many, many others will be in play. $70M, 5 years. He put together a postseason for the ages. He hits the best pitching and is very versatile, which could put him in play for a lot of teams. The Angels make particular sense, though. $64M, 4 years. He fit the Royals perfectly, as he filled in for Gordon while he was out, then filled in for second baseman Omar Infante when he was out. KC likely won’t bring him back, but he could wind up almost anywhere else. $60M, 4 years. Like Murphy, he enhanced his value big-time in October. Despite being a soft tosser he thrived in a tough park and in a very tough division. Maybe he’s turning a corner. $56M, 4 years. Hard to believe, he was second among free agent starters in strikeouts per nine innings (to Price). He rallied after a slow start and should do fine. The Brewers, Tigers and others make sense. $52M, 4 years. His big postseason should serve him well. The Astros may look for more of an on-base guy for left field, though. Quirkiness hurt him last time, but the big finish supersedes that. $50M. 4 years. He did a wonderful job as the leadoff man on the North Side. $48M, 4 years. He’s a fine hitting second baseman and a plus in any clubhouse. $44M, 4 years. He’s a switch-hitting catcher with power, and while he didn’t have a particularly good year, he’s the best catcher out there. He’ll be a year removed from Tommy John surgery. $42M, 3 years. He put together another very nice season in St. Louis (for the minimum, no less). He won’t have to take the minimum this time. $42M, 3 years. He’s still young but he’s been through a lot, and also a lot of ups and downs. Didn’t quite do it later after a nice beginning for his hometown team. $39M, 3 years. An injury-plagued year kept the Nats from extending the qualifying offer. That will actually help him. $36M, 3 years. He had a big first half with the Brewers, and excellent technical play has won him admirers (among them: Baltimore manager Buck Showalter, Nats GM Mike Rizzo). Those two teams could be among those in play. $33M, 3 years. He hasn’t won the batting title as predicted, but he is a league average third baseman with a knack in the clutch. $30M, 3 years. He’s a great defender in center field, although he had a rough year at bat and wound up as mostly a defensive replacement. Big plus: no qualifying offer. $30M, 3 years. He came back in time to save his free agency status. The qualifying offer is a bit of a drag here, though. He probably goes back to the Mariners. $28M, 2 years. Hard to believe he got a qualifying offer. But the Dodgers obviously like this fellow. If he doesn’t take the one-year bid maybe he turns it into two in LA. $25M, 2 years. He became the latest pitcher to discover something great in Pittsburgh. Also made himself a lot of money. Probably best to stay with the Pirates. $25M, 2 years. The terrific set-up man was previously excised by both the Angels and Mets. But after a career resurrection in Baltimore, he is extremely popular. The Tigers, Red Sox, Dodgers and Nats are said to be at the forefront of talks. $25M, 3 years. He had his moments in 2015 and is especially good vs. lefties (.138 BA). $21M, 3 years. Things didn’t end well in Washington, but perhaps he becomes a bargain with a change of scenery. $20M, 2 years. Big second half should get him a multiyear deal this time. $20M, 2 years. He looks like he’s back to his old self, and should draw major interest. $16M, 2 years. He could have won Comeback honors, and should now turn it into a multiyear deal. Good for him. $15M, 2 years. He’s turned himself into an excellent defensive first baseman, and he hit better when he got back to Texas. $15M, 2 years. He’s played well in the Bronx, and with depth at a premium, he should do well. $11M, 2 years. He became a sensation in New York as much for his hitting as his pitching. Just an amazing man. $10M, 1 year. He was hoping to have his $5.5 million option picked up but he should do as well as a free agent after a nice first half. $10M, 2 years. He proved to be a useful piece in Baltimore. $10M, 2 years. The defense is still holding up. $8M, 1 year. The $10 million option was declined but he looked much better in the second half. $8M, 1 year.

45. Chris Young, SP

His big October performance can’t hurt. The Royals would like him back. $7M, 1 year. He remains a solid performer, and his first postseason ended with a ring. $7M, 1 year. He can hit, he can run and he can play some center field. $6M, 1 year. His $7 million option was declined, but he should still get close to that number. $6M, 1 year. He may do better with new scenery. $6M, 1 year. The Giants are hoping to get him back on a non-guaranteed deal. But his doctor is predicting big things. $5M guaranteed (plus incentives).

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.